The debate on the mechanism of dithiobenzoate-mediated RAFT polymerization may be overcome by taking the so-called “missing step” reaction between a highly reactive propagating radical and the three-arm star-shaped product of the combination reaction of an intermediate RAFT radical and a propagating radical into account. The “missing step” reaction transforms a propagating radical and a not overly stable three-arm star species into a resonance-stabilized RAFT intermediate radical and a stable polymer molecule. The enormous driving force behind the “missing step” reaction is estimated via DFT calculations of reaction enthalpies and reaction free enthalpies.